What’s the Best Rated Diaper Pail?

Published: December 26, 2017

twitterpinterest

best rated diaper pail

The diaper pail is probably one of the most underrated piece of baby gear. Parents who find out that they are expecting a baby are often excited about purchasing stylish cribs, adorable onesies, the most high-tech rocker that could put a baby to sleep in five minutes and what not – rarely would they think about purchasing a diaper pail first. After all, what could be more unglamorous than a receptacle for storing poop-filled diapers? However, little do first-time parents know (myself included), that a diaper pail can be the best gift anyone could ever give you especially during the first few months when the baby is a living and breathing poop machine. No one wants to walk by a room and smell dirty diapers, even if it did come from the cutest baby on the block. So yes, a diaper pail can be one of your best allies during the diaper-changing phase. If you are looking for the best diaper pail for your money, you will want to consider the information below to find a diaper pail that will control odors and is easy to use. If you have a diaper pail that doesn’t control odors, you may as well just buy a regular garbage can. However, if you think that you cannot survive smelling a soiled diaper 24/7, then getting a diaper pail is an absolute necessity. A lot of diaper pails claim to be the best, but you never really know unless you test them out yourself. To help you on your search for the best diaper pail, I have narrowed down your options to the top four. After all, a smelly diaper is no joke. Scroll down for my picks!

Key Features

Odor Control

The whole point of getting a diaper pail as opposed to buying a trash can is to control odors. No one wants to smell a stinky diaper, and if the diaper pail isn’t doing its job, then you’re just wasting your money. You want a diaper pail that will contain odors completely and prevent any lingering smell in your nursery.

Ease of Use and Convenience

A diaper pail shouldn’t be complicated to use. It’s supposed to make the lives of sleep-deprived parents easier and more convenient, especially when changing diapers in the wee hours of the morning. You want a diaper pail that you can access even with your eyes closed and with one or no hands. No one has the time to operate a complicated diaper pail system when you have a baby screaming his or her lungs out. Another thing to look out for is a pail that ensures that the refill bag stays in place no matter how many diapers you throw in it. Lastly, the bag shouldn’t be difficult to remove once full, and it should also be easy to replace.

Capacity

How many used diapers can it contain? The bigger the capacity, the better, as it saves you from taking out the trash too often.

Other Features

You want a diaper pail that is cost-effective – no one wants to spend more money on refills than they do on the actual diapers! Some diaper pails can transition to a garbage pail once you get through the diaper stage, so you will always have a use for it, ensuring that you get the most value for your money. Some diaper pails have lid/child locks to prevent pets or toddlers from getting in there and making a huge, stinky mess. It also wouldn’t hurt if the diaper pail looks stylish or attractive. After all, it will be an almost permanent fixture in the nursery so why choose a pail that would be an eyesore in the months or even years to come when you can easily coordinate it with your décor?

Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Assembled Diaper Pail with Odor Lock Technology & 1 Full Size Refill, White (1 pail and 1 refill per unit)
Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail, Gray
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer
Ubbi Money Saving, No Special Bag Required, Steel Odor Locking Diaper Pail, Gray
Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Assembled Diaper Pail with Odor Lock Technology & 1 Full Size Refill, White (1 pail and 1 refill per unit)
Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail, Gray
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer
Ubbi Money Saving, No Special Bag Required, Steel Odor Locking Diaper Pail, Gray
$39.99
from $39.95
$64.99
$67.74
Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Assembled Diaper Pail with Odor Lock Technology & 1 Full Size Refill, White (1 pail and 1 refill per unit)
Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Assembled Diaper Pail with Odor Lock Technology & 1 Full Size Refill, White (1 pail and 1 refill per unit)
$39.99
Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail, Gray
Dekor Plus Hands-Free Diaper Pail, Gray
from $39.95
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer
Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer
$64.99
Ubbi Money Saving, No Special Bag Required, Steel Odor Locking Diaper Pail, Gray
Ubbi Money Saving, No Special Bag Required, Steel Odor Locking Diaper Pail, Gray
$67.74

Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail

The Diaper Genie is one of the most well-known brands when it comes to diaper pails. It was developed in the 90s and has since been making the lives of parents easier. The Diaper Genie Complete is currently the only Diaper Genie model with a foot pedal, which in my opinion, makes it the best model out of the three that are currently out in the market.

Odor Control

The Diaper Genie boasts an Ultimate Odor Lock System that is designed to contain odors – from the time that you place the used diaper in the pail, to waiting for it to fill up, and finally, to when you have to replace the bag with a new one. It works by having a built-in odor controlling, anti-microbial, and double airtight clamps to seal in odors within the pail. To further neutralize unpleasant day-old diaper smells, it has a carbon filter installed at the top of the bin. If that’s not enough, the bags have 7 layers to help seal off odors. All those features ensure that your nursery will be stink-free all day, every day.

Ease of Use and Convenience

The Diaper Genie comes assembled right out of the box with the bags already installed, so you can immediately use it. What I love about it is that it has a foot pedal, so all you have to do is step on the pedal and toss the diaper in – no hands required to open! Replacing the bag is convenient as well because of the front tilt bin. You only need to pull the bag through the cutter that’s built in, then tie it. Easy peasy!

Capacity

Playtex claims that the refill cassette can hold up to 270 newborn diapers. As for each bag, 20 is a safe number before you find that you have to change the bag (which is around every 2-3 days). Not changing the bag every day is already a plus for me, since throwing out the trash with stinky and poop-filled diapers can be wearisome if you have to do it all the time.

Other Features

The Diaper Genie Complete comes in five colors – pastel-tones and white – all of which are soothing to the eyes and are guaranteed to match any nursery. In terms of cost, buying the refills can get pricey since the Diaper Genie is not compatible with standard trash bags. Carbon filters also need to be replaced once you start to notice that it doesn’t hold in the smell effectively.

See the Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail on Amazon.

Dekor Plus Diaper Pail

Another great option is the Dekor Plus Diaper Pail. It claims to be 100% hands-free, which means disposing of a used diaper doesn’t require bending, twisting, or squishing to get it into the pail. If you’re someone who gets pretty grossed out by a dirty diaper and wants the easiest way to dispose of it, the Dekor Plus may just be the best solution for you.

Odor Control

The Dekor Plus has an Odorkeeper Trap Door which is spring loaded so you just drop the diaper in, and it will automatically close afterward.  It is made of tough ABS plastic which prevents it from absorbing odors in the long run. The refills are powder-scented which not only contains odors, but helps to keep your nursery smell fresh longer.

Ease of Use and Convenience

As with the Diaper Genie, the Dekor Plus can be used right out of the box and comes with a pre-installed, full-sized refill. It has a foot pedal that you step on to open the lid and access the trap door where the diaper will be dropped, and you don’t need to touch the pail in the process – convenient and hygienic at the same time! It has a self-closing lid that closes quietly, so your baby won’t be disturbed while he or she is sleeping. Changing the bag is convenient as well because its easy access door opens wide.

Capacity

It can hold up to 60 newborn diapers before it needs to be emptied, and the refill can hold up to a whopping 580 newborn diapers in total! That’s a lot of diapers before you need to purchase a refill, which equates to savings in the long run!

Other Features

The Dekor Plus comes in five colors as well – white, pink, gray, mint, and blue – so you can choose the color which best complements your nursery. It has child-proof features as well. The Odorkeeper Trap Door has a safety lock that works by turning, and the front button keeps the top frame closed to prevent children from getting access to the icky contents of the diaper pail. What is notable about the Dekor Plus is that it aims to be eco-friendly with its reusable cartridge and biodegradable refills that are made with 20% recycled material. Another great feature is that you can use the Dekor Plus for cloth diapers. Just purchase the Dekor Cloth Diaper Pail Liner and use it again and again to keep your soiled cloth diapers until the next laundry day. Once you’re done using it as a diaper pail, remove the diaper insert and it can turn into a regular, (albeit more stylish) garbage can.

See the Dekor Plus Diaper Pail on Amazon.

Munchkin STEP Diaper Pail

The Munchkin STEP Diaper Pail is another great diaper pail to consider in terms of odor control. We are all familiar with Arm & Hammer and their cleaning supplies, and they have teamed up with Munchkin to offer the best odor control of all diaper pails. Munchkin plants a tree for every diaper pail sold, which is pretty cool too. To date, they have planted almost 200,000 trees – that equates to a lot of STEP Diaper Pails sold!

Odor Control

It has a self-sealing system that locks in odors because the bag stays sealed when you open the lid. This means that you won’t get a whiff of unpleasant odors every time you use it. It also has a lavender-scented baking soda puck that is located under the lid, so your nursery will smell like fresh flowers instead of day-old poop. The 7-layer bags are designed to contain odors and are lavender-scented as well.

Ease of Use and Convenience

It has a foot pedal for hands-free access, making it breeze to throw the used diaper while holding the baby with one hand. However, unlike the other brands, you have to put the diaper (kind of squishing it) through the hole instead of tossing it in, which takes a bit more effort. The STEP is compatible with two types of refills, the Arm & Hammer Snap Seal & Toss bags and the Arm & Hammer Refill Rings. I personally prefer the Snap Seal & Toss because the bags are separate and not a continuous roll, eliminating the need to cut and tie the bag when it’s time to change it. Just snap the bag in and you’re done!

Capacity

The STEP can hold approximately 20 to 25 diapers before you need to change it, which is not that much.  However, it still gives you a couple of days before you need to change it.

Other Features

Although the Munchkin STEP Diaper Pail only comes in white, it has clean lines which make for a sleek and stylish look. It has a child-lock as well. Besides the self-sealing technology that’s patented by Munchkin, it doesn’t have other features that stand out. However, it is a very effective diaper pail when it comes to odor control, so if that is your priority, then your search for the perfect diaper pail is over.

See the Munchkin STEP Diaper Pail on Amazon.

Ubbi Diaper Pail

The Ubbi Diaper Pail is the only one in this list that has a powder-coated steel body. It does not absorb odors unlike plastic, which can trap smells after prolonged use, even after countless cleaning or sanitizing. It is also durable and sturdy so you can get years of use out of it.

Odor Control

In addition to its steel body that keeps in odors, the Ubbi Diaper Pail has rubber seals around its lid, making it airtight. Its unique lid design ensures that it minimizes air disruption every time you slide it open so that you don’t get a huge whiff of smelly diapers.

Ease of Use and Convenience

Although Ubbi has plastic bags and cloth liners that you can purchase separately, the diaper pail does not require special refills or bags, so any standard trash bag or even reusable cloth liner will do. The Ubbi Diaper Pail is probably the easiest to use when it comes to changing and removing the liner/bag. Just tuck the bag around the bag holder and it’s ready to use. To remove, lift the lid and bag holder, tie the bag, then pull it out. Changing and removing the bag won’t be odor free, but it’s only for a few seconds anyway. With the savings you’ll get from not having to buy specialized refills, that’s a pretty good trade-off in the long run.

Capacity

It can hold up to 50 newborn-sized diapers, which is quite an impressive amount.

Other Features

The Ubbi comes in an array of 12 colors (ranging from pastel to bright) that’s guaranteed to match any nursery decor.  It looks sleek, so it will not be an eyesore no matter where you decide to place it. It has safety features too – a child safety lock hinders access to the contents of the pail, and the slow closing lid prevents fingers from getting injured. Although you have to pay a bit more for the Ubbi than the other diaper pail brands, you will get long term savings because you can use any trash bag with it as compared to using special bags that can get to be expensive.

See the Ubbi Diaper Pail on Amazon.

The Verdict

For parents who juggle a lot of tasks, throwing out a trash-full of smelly, dirty diapers everyday can be tiresome. That’s why diaper pails are quickly becoming a necessity. Not only are diaper pails essential to keeping a nursery (and your entire house) odor-free, but it can help save your sanity as well since it doesn’t require you to change the bag everyday (unless your little one uses up more than 20 diapers a day, which is highly unlikely). There are a few things to consider when choosing a diaper pail, and it’s up to you to choose the best pail that would work for your needs.

Most Budget-Friendly: Diaper Genie Complete Diaper Pail

With a price that’s just above $30, the Diaper Genie Complete is the cheapest diaper pail that you can get that doesn’t compromise on features. It has an odor control system which includes airtight clamps and a carbon filter, and its foot pedal makes it convenient to operate hands-free.

Easiest to Operate:  Dekor Plus Diaper Pail

The Dekor Plus doesn’t need hands to operate, which makes it the most convenient to use. There’s no need to squish the diaper through the opening – all you have to do is toss it in after pressing the foot pedal and you’re done. Its biodegradable bags and refillable cartridge, plus the fact that you can use a cloth liner with it, make it the eco-friendliest option as well.

Best in Odor Control: Munchkin STEP Diaper Pail

The Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer is the most versatile of the diaper pails listed, and it offers the best odor control. This diaper pail can be used with Arm & Hammer Snap Seal & Toss bags and the Arm & Hammer Refill Rings so you get to choose what is the most convenient for you. The self-sealing system guarantees to keep odors at bay, and the lavender-scented carbon pucks and refills will ensure that your nursery smells fresh all day, everyday.

Best Value for Your Money: Ubbi Diaper Pail

The Ubbi Diaper Pail may be the most expensive option out of all the four brands listed here, but it will give you long term savings since you don’t need to purchase special refills to use it. Although standard trash bags can be used with it, odors will still be contained in the pail because of its rubber seal and steel body. You may be shelling out more money upfront, but its quality will ensure that it’s the only diaper pail that you will ever need. Its innovative design and durable steel body will resist breakage, giving you years of use out of it.

No matter which brand you get, having a diaper pail will definitely make your life easy – once you’ve started using one, you will never go back to a plain and boring garbage can!

Like our diaper pail picks? Be sure to check out our other product recommendations, including best scales for breastfeeding and best bottle warmer for Medela bottles (and other kinds, too!)


Categorised in:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge